Sunday, November 15, 2026

Nat Banting's Menu Math Review

In his menu math activities, Nat Banting asked teachers and students to focus on developing “upstream thinking.” In-context problems from more traditional textbooks will often provide a function or equation for the students to work with. Students recognize that this is usually all they need to pay attention to, and the broader context is ignored. Banting describes this as downstream thinking, where the model is given to the student and they use it to solve for a specific graphical feature (potentially like an intercept, a minimum, or a maximum) or provide general interpretation of what the function is and does.

In contrast, upstream thinking involves being given the specifications, the requirements of a particular function. For example, it needs to have some number of x-intercepts, or it needs to be open- or downward-opening if it's a parabola. Students then are required to work backwards to figure out what type of model has that particular property. He adds the additional challenge of the menu, in which students have a set of requirements (specifications for the particular model). They must figure out how to be as efficient as possible in satisfying all of these specifications with the minimum number of functions.

Overall, this feels like a useful idea, and I will try it out at some point with students. This seems like a great low-floor, high-ceiling activity. Students who are uncomfortable with the efficiency ask can just focus on identifying a function that satisfies two or even one requirement, but students who are more comfortable can try to maximize the number of menu choices satisfied for a given function. I particularly like this efficiency challenge, which requires students to think strategically. Banting describes it as a “metacognitive” task.

I was somewhat confused about some of the other in-context problems he was discussing and how they qualified as downstream. For example, he presents a problem that doesn't give the students the equation or function at the beginning but instead describes the features of a particular relationship and asks students to then derive the function. His argument, I believe, is that because the students are looking for a very particular relationship, they still ignore the context; but this still feels like upstream thinking, just perhaps a contrived version of it. 

Browsing through the website with other menu math activities, I don't see a lot of context. I would be curious about how we might be able to adapt this in a way that doesn’t abandon it, but instead incentivizes students to consider what real-world situation a mathematical relationship is describing.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Nat Banting's Menu Math Review

In his menu math activities, Nat Banting asked teachers and students to focus on developing “upstream thinking.” In-context problems from mo...