Sunday, November 15, 2026

Nat Banting's Menu Math Review

In his menu math activities, Nat Banting asked teachers and students to focus on developing “upstream thinking.” In-context problems from more traditional textbooks will often provide a function or equation for the students to work with. Students recognize that this is usually all they need to pay attention to, and the broader context is ignored. Banting describes this as downstream thinking, where the model is given to the student and they use it to solve for a specific graphical feature (potentially like an intercept, a minimum, or a maximum) or provide general interpretation of what the function is and does.

In contrast, upstream thinking involves being given the specifications, the requirements of a particular function. For example, it needs to have some number of x-intercepts, or it needs to be open- or downward-opening if it's a parabola. Students then are required to work backwards to figure out what type of model has that particular property. He adds the additional challenge of the menu, in which students have a set of requirements (specifications for the particular model). They must figure out how to be as efficient as possible in satisfying all of these specifications with the minimum number of functions.

Overall, this feels like a useful idea, and I will try it out at some point with students. This seems like a great low-floor, high-ceiling activity. Students who are uncomfortable with the efficiency ask can just focus on identifying a function that satisfies two or even one requirement, but students who are more comfortable can try to maximize the number of menu choices satisfied for a given function. I particularly like this efficiency challenge, which requires students to think strategically. Banting describes it as a “metacognitive” task.

I was somewhat confused about some of the other in-context problems he was discussing and how they qualified as downstream. For example, he presents a problem that doesn't give the students the equation or function at the beginning but instead describes the features of a particular relationship and asks students to then derive the function. His argument, I believe, is that because the students are looking for a very particular relationship, they still ignore the context; but this still feels like upstream thinking, just perhaps a contrived version of it. 

Browsing through the website with other menu math activities, I don't see a lot of context. I would be curious about how we might be able to adapt this in a way that doesn’t abandon it, but instead incentivizes students to consider what real-world situation a mathematical relationship is describing.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Group Microlesson Reflection

 

 

 Overall, this project felt like something of a mixed bag. I really enjoyed working with my fellow group members. However, I think the combination of the short time frame, having four group members with sometimes different ideas about what we should do, and the requirement that we not engage in "your turn, my turn" type lecturing made this a big challenge. A strange additional challenge was the subject matter itself: theoretical probability just has so many easy and engaging applications for students that I think it made it hard for us to narrow it down to a few key activities and learning goals. 

Our ultimate structure was ambitious. We tried to have a shared introduction, followed by breaking into two separate groups, and then hoped to have a conclusion where we bring everyone back together and discuss the results of the two different groups. Unfortunately, we did not do a good job of time management and ran out of time for the conclusion, which made the ending of the lesson unsatisfying.

Some key takeaways from this activity for me are that sometimes you just have to decide about what a lesson is going to look like, regardless of whether it's the ideal lesson. Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good or the easily-completed-in-a-short-time-frame. I also think we learned a lot about communication. Some of our struggles with deciding on a final lesson plan were miscommunications in a purely text-based communication medium. Izhar mentioned a few times how it might be more productive to have a Zoom chat. However, we never took him up on this, and in retrospect this was likely the better approach.

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Pro-D Day Reflection

I participated in the professional development day at the Beatty Biodiversity Museum. While there I took a tour, watched a movie about how the museum got its blue whale skeleton, explored the stacks, and visited the booths.

Though I would be fascinated by attending a mathematics museum (and hopefully some of my students would be), I have a suspicion that a science museum like the Beatty Museum would be a more preferred location for many secondary school students. So I considered how I might be able to take a math class to the Beatty Museum. Some ideas I had were fractal patterns in nature; genetics and statistics; population growth models , particularly with regard to the urchin-kelp forest story and whaling; scale models of animals; radiocarbon dating and half-life models; volumes, surface areas, and limits on organism size; unit conversion; symmetry; and sine waves and whale vocalizations. 

I was surprised to learn that the museum was also a research facility. I would like to know more about how the research is conducted at the Beatty Museum. What sort of projects are being worked on? I was also curious about a story the tour guide related to us involving an individual who had collected an impressive collection of plant specimens from around BC and then donated it to the Beatty Museum. It reminds me of a book I recently read called The Great Auk: Its Extraordinary Life, Hideous Death and Mysterious Afterlife, which discussed how important private collections have been for establishing and pressuring knowledge of natural life. Unfortunately for the Great Auk, this collecting also led to its eventual extinction. 


Saturday, October 17, 2026

Microlesson Reflection

 



Overall, I was happy with my micro lesson on birdwatching. I had a lot of fun designing the handouts, presentation, and activities for a beloved hobby. I tried to include multiple ways for the students to learn, including audio, physical objects and handouts, and a presentation.


Both Alea and Izhar correctly identified that I was missing a solid introduction. I had a longer introductory hook at one point, but I got rid of it due to time constraints. I still need to include something to grab students' attention and can't just assume that because I’m interested in something, they will be too. Though they did seem to enjoy practicing with the binoculars, Eliah was correct that this part of the activity was distracting. It would be quite easy for students younger than my classmates to just play around with the binoculars and not pay attention to the other things I was trying to teach. Perhaps something like "Beginning Binocular Use for Baby Birders" would have been better, and I should have skipped the activity involving identifying key visual features of birds.

As I often do, I overstuffed this lesson. I'm happy that I made one slide for “if time allows,” but it was still not enough. My time management issues were likely downstream from how much I enjoyed putting together this lesson. It’s good to be passionate about the material and explore engaging ways to present it, but I must also be aware of simple logistical constraints like time. No matter how entertaining or interesting a topic or activity is, if the students are rushed through it, they will grow confused, overwhelmed, and disinterested.









Wednesday, October 14, 2026

Microlesson Teaching Plan and Materials

Subject / course: EDCP 342

Date and duration: October 14, 2026, 10 minutes

Topic or lesson title: "Birdwatching Basics for Beginning Birders"

Learning objectives

  1. Identify key features of birds
  2. Learn to use binoculars

Materials: Binoculars, "birds", Merlin app, presentation, notebooks, pencils, handout with key features of bird and "bird suspects," Ipad, speaker for playing bird song


Differentiation: some students may have visual impairments that makes use of binoculars difficult


Classroom prep: Clean binoculars, presentation set up, make sure there is space to separate students from laptop and a table/chair for laptop.


Lesson sequence


Stage

Duration

Time

What the teacher does

What students do

Hook / warm-up

1 min

0:01

Ask familiarity with birds, binoculars, formative assessment

Listen, respond to teacher questions

Activity 1

2-3 min

0:04

Binocular usage, key features of robin,

formative assessment

Practice with binoculars, ask questions

Activity 2

3-5 min

0:08

Mystery bird identification activity, formative assessment

Practice binocular usage, identifying bird, discuss

"Not a neutral hobby"


1-2 min

0:09

Problematize birdwatching and ornithology

Listen, comment, look through birdbook

Conclusion

1 min

0:10

Conclusion

Listen, reflect, comment, applaud and compliment the teacher

Reflection

What worked?

What would you change?

Time management?

Who needs follow-up?


SLIDESHOW:











Handout:

























Monday, October 12, 2026

Malihe Presentation Reflection

I appreciated the activities that Malihe engaged us with during her lesson. I think it was a useful way of learning how difficult it can be for immigrants to access the resources they need to thrive in their new countries if there are language or cultural barriers. It was also interesting learning about the Iranian educational system and comparing it to Canada’s, as well as the Persian number system.


One thing I was unsure of was how similar these challenges are to those faced by immigrants in Canada. I am admittedly a privileged immigrant: white, middle-class, and anglophone; however, I remember an abundance of cultural and language-specific resources available to me as part of becoming a permanent resident. I also wonder about how common it is for immigrants in Canada to seek out information via searching on the web. My understanding is that it is common for newly arrived immigrants to join already established communities and use these networks to navigate their new world.

At the same time, there will be immigrants who are not be able to take advantage of this. I would assume social isolation is more common among refugees and asylum seekers. It also may be the case that the immigrants specifically left their home countries to avoid staying in familiar communities and cultures. It is important that immigrants in this position still have information about how to access resources.

Nat Banting's Menu Math Review

In his menu math activities, Nat Banting asked teachers and students to focus on developing “upstream thinking.” In-context problems from mo...